For that person must not suppose that he will receive anything from the Lord;
According to verse 7, does the one who doubts in verse 6 receive wisdom if he asks for it? To say no is to disprove the premise of verse 6, that God gives generously to those who ask, giving without reproach. Does God give without reproach even to the doubter? The one in the mindset of doubt will say no, the one in the mindset of faith says yes, that God upholds his promises and I believe it.
Turn the coin over. What if this isn’t a God problem. What if the problem in receiving wisdom lies within the fallen nature of man? Now that seems more plausible. God, being perfect, fulfills his promises while man, being flawed and needing to renew his mind, may not see that he has received the promise due to the obscurity he has in the mind as a result of the fallen nature.
We like to blame shift, but on this one, I see a man problem, not a God problem. This is why James says that the doubter should not suppose (think, believe, imagine) that he has received, not just wisdom, but anything from God. This person who is doubting needs a reset of the mind. He needs to stop operating out of two psychosis. This man needs to operate fully from the new self, which is driven by the knowledge of Christ in him.
Therefore when one doubts, one needs to stop thinking all together about the relation between God and his blessings and refocus on the elementary principle of the Gospel, that he needs to repent, i.e. change his mind.
But let him ask in faith, with no doubting, for the one who doubts is like a wave of the sea that is driven and tossed by the wind.
According to James, people can be like waves. Therefore I went to the pet store and asked to buy a pet wave. They laughed me out of the store. So I went to my front yard and caught one. He was just sitting there doing nothing. In fact there were a whole bunch of them surrounding my koi. The wave was easy to catch, let me tell you. I snuck up on him like a tiger in eager patience for his next dinner. When I sprung, I landed right on him and put him straight into his 20 oz cage. I immediately named him Splash and we started training. My first trick was to teach Splash to sit. Unfortunately, the moment I let him out of his cage he fell apart and became divided and was no more.
The doubting man is like a wave of the sea. He is driven and tossed by anything and everything that comes his way because he has no ability to be controlled from within. James says that wind will toss the wave around. It doesn’t take just wind to move water, a boat can cut a wave in half, likewise a sea gull can cause a wave to also be disturbed.
When one doubts, he does not operate from the power of faith in him which has the ability to control and steady him in the trials of life. Like a wave he is controlled by external circumstances that toss him around. Therefore he needs to return to belief and trust that God has given him the wisdom he needs to continue in his trial.
Now to go catch me a gust of wind. “(Whistle, Whistle), Come here Breeze.”